Welcome to Ransomware Case Study- City
of Atlanta, brought to you by IBM. In this video, you will learn to define the timeline of
the City of Atlanta Ransomware Breach. Learn about what actions were
taken by the threat actors. And learn what the impacts
are from a ransomware attack. In the early morning of March 22, 2018, the City of Atlanta suffered
a widespread ransomware attack. The ransomware incident knocked out
services such as warrant issuances, water request, new inmate processing,
court fee payments, and online bill pay programs across
multiple city departments. The virus used to attack the city was
the SamSam Ransomware which differs from other ransomware in that it does not
rely on phishing, but rather utilizes a brute force attack to guess weak
passwords until a match is found. It is known to Target weaker it
infrastructures and servers. To unlock the city systems and
data hackers demanded 51,000 in Bitcoin, which the city refused to pay. Now let's review
the timeline of the attack. In the early morning of March 22, a large ransomware cyber attack dealt
a widespread blow to the City of Atlanta, the state capital and
home to the nation's busiest airport. The breach shuttered many
devices at City Hall for about five days in an extensive infection. Elsewhere across the enterprise it
significantly impacted law enforcement temporally returning police to
writing incident reports by hand and costing the department access to nearly
all its archived and vehicle video. It also affected internal and
external facing applications alike forcing the manual processing of
cases at Atlanta Municipal Court and stopping online or in-person payments
of tickets, water bills, and business licenses, and renewals. Out of caution,
officials also disable the Wi-Fi at Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta
International Airport until April 2nd. In May, the city restored its
online water bill payment system. And the court's online
bill payment option and docket boards weren't returned
to service until June. Let's go ahead and review some vulnerabilities
that we seen with this attack. There was no plan in place
if an attack occurred. There are many lessons learned for the City of Atlanta that
we will explore later. First of all inability is
operations during the attack. Despite the breach,
Atlanta's 911 system and its emergency response were unaffected,
and major utilities including water and sewer services continued unabated. This was possible because Atlanta retained
the manual processes and institutional knowledge it needed to revert to
traditional methods of service provision and had plans in place to keep doing
business while the incident unfolded. So city responded to the breach,
business continuity, and operational impact assessment
were going on simultaneously. A lot of municipalities and
private sector counterparts get so caught up in the response effort that
they don't recognize that as part of that response you should immediately begin
thinking about how you're going to continue operations. According to Ria Atkin Atlanta's Director
of the Office of Emergency Preparedness. He also didn't understand the impact
of the threat on all operations. Systems were being evaluated
as the threat was happening. They also had some vulnerabilities
around the readiness of systems. Leading up to the attack,
the Atlanta government was criticized for a lack of spending on upgrading its
IT infrastructure leaving multiple vulnerabilities open to attack. In fact, a January 2018 audit found
1,500 to 2,000 vulnerabilities in the city systems, and suggested that
the number of vulnerabilities had so large that workers grew complacent. So what was the cost of this breach? The SamSam ransomware attack that took
down the city of Atlanta's computer network in March could cost
taxpayers up to $17 million, up from earlier estimates of 2.7 million. The latest cost estimate includes about 6
million in existing contracts for security services and software upgrades, and 11
million in potential costs associated with the attack including new desktop,
laptops, smartphones, and tablets. This would mark one of the US costliest
cyber attacks affecting a local government in 2018 despite city officials
declining to pay the ransom demanded by the attackers. Restoring services after ransomware
attacks is always financially and reputationally expensive
because of the cost of downtime during recovery calculated
to be about $10,000 per day. The City of Pensacola in Florida, for
example, is hit by a Maze Ransomware attack and a ransom demand a million
dollars in December of 2019. As of 2019, attacks spiked this year with
more than 70 state and local governments hit with ransomware according to the IT
security company Barracuda Networks. So let's look at some of the things
that could have been prevented. When it comes to best practices to
avoid a debilitating cyber attack, outright prevention should be
a goal says Verizon's Spitzer. IT officials must know
their network architecture, invest in email infrastructure,
and remain vigilant at all levels, scrutinizing emails and their attachments,
and looking for browser vulnerabilities. Multi-factor authentication is immensely
valuable and segmentation is crucial, he added. Finally, state and local governments
should have security zones segmented well within their own networks to
hinder bad actors from moving laterally should they open one
device by brute force. If you cannot get on one system, then you
cannot use that system to get on another. Also agencies are urged to have a plan to
do backups, to back up data regularly and make it secure, and to be prepared to
quickly take infected machines off the network should an incident or
breach occur. Local governments are also more
frequently opting to pay the ransom rather than rebuild their systems after
seeing Atlanta spend multi-million dollars to restore its systems rather
than pay the $52,000 ransom. Let's take a look at how the City
of Atlanta is moving forward. Atlanta officials highlighted the
importance of protecting government data and information and bringing discipline
to an agency's approach to cybersecurity. According to Rackley the city's approach
to cybersecurity rests on three pillars, governance with compliance, vulnerability
management, and overall threat management. In addition to limiting the financial
impact of an incident or breach, a cyber insurance policy can serve as
a roadmap and help an agency develop the sustained drive it needs to
further its cybersecurity goals. Part of the takeaway would be yes,
get insurance, but use that insurance in the process of
getting it to take a more critical look at what you're doing as a municipality. Also stressed by Hadley is the value
in connecting with potential partners in the public and private sectors
before an incident or breach occurs and of identifying available resources
before they may be critically needed. But equally valuable is the idea of taking
a step back from a smaller day-to-day test of enterprise-level IT management and
cybersecurity to see the larger view. Getting the big picture
can better inform c-level executives on the individual
surfaces in their enterprises. It can also help identify
existing IT investments and identify any road blocks such as siloing
and help reduce unnecessary applications. Since becoming Atlanta's CIO in October
2018, Atlanta Chief Information Officer, Gary Brantley,
has focused on building a continuity plan. So city officials know how to
continue operating city services, even if a cyber attack
takes down their networks. He compared preparation efforts
to school safety drills. When there's a disaster situation those
kids know exactly what to do, he said, because they've practiced it before. Wendi Whitmore, IBM's vice president
of X-Force Threat Intelligence said on this attack that running through
drills can reveal critical weaknesses that allow cyber attacks to
take plays as well as simple prevention efforts that can protect
against extensive damage. When an attack happens, city employees
might find they don't know how to reach their colleagues without city issue
devices and email accounts, for example. Or an agency might know to keep
backups of its data, she said. But if the backups are connected
to a compromised network, they could be corrupted
along with everything else. Next I will be discussing with you
peer-to-peer case study that you will be responsible for providing to
review, research, and analyzing skills.